|
European psychoanalytic group
for research and training on
the causes of illiteracy |
 |
|
Illiteracy,
topology and psychoanalysis :
What is Topology
?
Topology is a part of mathematics, as it is for geometry.
Topology ignores quantity and
only refers to quality.
Topology has its own tools like Borromean Knot, Möbius Strip,
Knots,
the Klein Bottle,
Roman Surface,
Boy Surface, Cross-Cap, and Torus.
|
|
.Topology
is a part of mathematics. Their
is two separate, distinct sections (one on general, point
set topology, the other on algebraic topology).
Independent topics and applications exist too, like in
psychoanalysis and in linguistics.
Texts
coming from :
http://curvebank.calstatela.edu and
http://www.cut-the-knot.org
The Möbius
Strip
A
Möbius strip is a two-dimensional surface with
only one side. It can be constructed in three
dimensions as follows. Take a rectangular strip
of paper and join the two ends of the strip
together so that it has a 180 degree twist. It
is now possible to start at a point A on
the surface and trace out a path that passes
through the point which is apparently on the
other side of the surface from A. But it
is not, in fact their is only one face. You must
follow one side and see that you will pass the
other side which is the same...
Significance of the Möbius Strip
(The hands-on
experiment is far better than any written
description.)
We suggest you make a Möbius
strip by cutting a band of about two inches in
width and at least 15 inches in length.
Give the band a half twist, and re-attach
the two ends. Then draw a line down the
middle of the band. With scissors,
cut the band along the pencil mark. Voilà!
One long cut produces two divisions but results
in only one new band. The half-twist
results in a one-sided surface.

Cutting a Möbius strip, giving
it additional twists, and reconnecting the ends
produce figures called "paradromic rings" that
are studied in topology.
There is an additional "twist"
to the history of the now famous strip. In
1847, Johann Benedict Listing published
Vorstudien zur Topologie. This was the first
published use of the word "topology."
Nearing bankruptcy in 1858, largely due to a
wife who could not control her spending, Listing
discovered the properties of the Möbius strip at
almost the same time as, and independently of,
Möbius. His publication included the
results of various twists, half-twists, cuts,
divisions and lengths. Four years later he
extended Euler's formula for the Euler
characteristic of oriented three-dimensional
polyhedra to the case of certain
four-dimensional simplicial complexes.
Today, a far larger audience
of mathematicians now knows the name of "Möbius"
and can recall the Euler Formula.
For related topics, a student
should also investigate the extensive literature
on the Klein Bottle,
Roman Surface, Boy Surface, Cross-Cap, and
Torus.
|
Sphere and Möbius strip
Sphere has two sides.
A bug may be
trapped inside a spherical shape
or crawl freely on its visible
surface. A thin sheet of paper
lying on a desk also have two
sides. Pages in a book are
usually numbered two per a sheet
of paper.
The first
one-sided surface was discovered
by
A. F. Möbius (1790-1868)

and bears his
name: Möbius strip. Sometimes
it's alternatively called a
Möbius band. (In truth, the
surface was described
independently and earlier by two
months by another German
mathematician
J. B. Listing.)
___________________________________________
The strip was
immortalized by M. C. Escher
(1898-1972).
Psychanalyse et Science
(Site of Alain Cochet)
Topology
is a branch of pure mathematics,
deals with the fundamental
properties of abstract spaces.
Whereas classical geometry is
concerned with measurable
quantities, such as angle,
distance, area, and so forth,
topology is concerned with
notations of continuity and
relative position. Point-set
topology regards geometrical
figures as collections of
points, with the entire
collection often considered a
space. Combinatorial or
algebraic topology treats
geometrical figures as
aggregates of smaller building
blocks.
BASIC CONCEPTS
In general, topologists
study properties of spaces that
remain unchanged, no matter how
the spaces are bent, stretched,
shrunk, or twisted.
Such transformations of ideally
elastic objects are subject only
to the condition that nearby
points in one space correspond
to nearby points in transformed
version of that space. Because
allowed deformation can be
carried out by manipulating a
rubber sheet, topology is
sometimes known as rubber-sheet
geometry. In contrast, cutting,
then gluing together parts of a
space is bound to fuse two or
more points and to separate
points once close together.
The basic ideas of topology
surfaced in the mid -19th
century as offshoots of algebra
and ANALYTIC GEOMETRY. Now the
field is a major mathematical
pursuit, with applications
ranging from cosmology and
particle physics to the
geometrical structure of
proteins and other molecules of
biological interest.
In essence, the topology of
a space provides a way of
telling which points are very
close to one another and which
are not. For instance, it
supplies a way of determining
whether a curve drawn on a space
is continuous (unbroken) or not.
However, it does not distinguish
between a smooth and crinkly
curve or say anything about the
curve's length. Topology does
not deal with smoothness or
size. Hence, a cube's surface
has the same topology as a
sphere's surface, even though
one has sharp corners and the
other smooth. Such topologically
identical figures are termed
homeomorphic. On the other hand,
the surface of a sphere has a
difficult topology from the
surface of a torus
(doughnut-shaped space).
A
primary aim of topology is to
find a serviceable set of rules
or procedures for recognizing
spaces in all dimensions. In
such a classification scheme,
two spaces would belong to the
same topological class if they
had the same basic, overall
structure although they might
differ drastically in their
details.
The simplest topological
spaces are known as Euclidean
spaces. In general, the term
DIMENSION signifies an
independent parameter, or
coordinate. A space has n
dimensions if each of its points
is completely determined by n
independent numbers. An
infinitely long line is a
one-dimension Euclidean space.
The plane is a two-dimensional
Euclidean space. The space of
ordinary experience is usually
considered a three-dimensional
Euclidean space.
MANIFOLDS
The term manifold
covers more complicated types
than Euclidean spaces. Manifolds
locally appear flat, or
Euclidean, but on a larger scale
may bend and twist into exotic
and intricate forms. Any
surface, however curved and
complicated, so long as it does
not intersect itself, can be
thought of as consisting of
small, two-dimensional,
Euclidean patches glued
together.
Special manifold
characteristics, often expressed
as numbers or algebraic
expressions, help distinguish
manifolds. Such expressions,
known as topological invariants,
provide a convenient way of
categorizing manifolds.
Dimension, the number of
coordinates required to specify
a point in a given space, is one
example of a topological
invariant. Manifolds may also be
either bounded or unbounded. A
circle is an example of a
bounded, one-dimensional
manifold, but a line stretching
off indefinitely in both
directions is unbounded. The
same distinction applies to
spaces of any dimension.
Certain types of two-manifolds,
termed compact surfaces, can be
classified in terms of an
invariant called the Euler
number. For a compact surface
divided into triangles, the
surface's Euler number equals
the number of triangles minus
the number of edges plus the
number of vertices (a vertex is
the point of a triangle farthest
from its base). No matter how
the surface is divided up into
triangles--so long as no
triangle's vertex rests on
another triangle's edge--each
different type of compact
surface has a particular Euler
number. The sphere has Euler
number 2; the torus has Euler
number 0; the surface of a
two-handled soup tureen has a
Euler number of -2. Each even
integer less than or equal to 2
is the Euler number for exactly
one type of closed surface.
The same idea can be
expressed in terms of spheres to
which are attached a certain
number of handles. The surface
of a sphere or a lump of clay
fall into one group, whereas the
surface of a doughnut or a
coffee mug fall into another.
Because both forms have one
hole, one can imagine smoothly
deforming a doughnut-shaped
piece of clay to produce a mug
with a single handle. On the
other hand, there is no way,
short of cutting, to turn a
spherical balloon into an inner
tube.
Topologists, using suitable
invariations, can examine in
detail what manifolds look like
and how one can be transformed
into another. Much manifold
study concerns the search for
more finely tuned invariants
that make subtler distinctions.
Because manifolds in higher
dimensions are impossible to
visualize, these invariants
often stand in for the
manifolds.
MANIFOLD CLASSIFICATION
Mathematicians have developed
workable schemes for studying
manifolds in every dimension
except three and four. Dimension
three remains a puzzle because
proposed classification schemes
cover only a portion of all
conceivable three-manifolds.
Recent attempts to demystify
four-dimensional spaces reveal
them to have special
characteristics quite unlike
those of any dimension, higher
or lower. The Poincare
conjecture, named for the French
mathematician Henri POINCARE,
ranks as one of the most
baffling and challenging
unsolved problems in algebraic
topology.
The central idea of homotopy
theory (the theory of the
relationship between
topologically identical spaces)
is to reduce topological
questions to abstract algebra by
associating with topological
spaces various algebraic
invariants. Poincare's
contribution was the invention
of an abstract concept called
the fundamental group for
distinguishing different
categories of two-dimensional
surfaces. Poincare was able to
show that any two-dimensional
surface having the same
fundamental group as the
two-dimensional surface of a
sphere is topologically
equivalent to such a sphere. He
then conjectured that the same
relationship holds for
three-dimensional manifolds, and
other mathematicians extended
the idea to higher dimensions.
Ironically, mathematicians have
provided the equivalent of
Poincare's conjecture for all
dimensions except three.
The central problem in proving
the conjecture in three
dimensions is that, unlike the
two-manifolds cases, topologists
have no complete classification
scheme for three-manifolds.
There exists no list of all
possible manifolds that can be
checked one by one to make sure
that all have different homotopy
groups.
KNOT THEORY
Topology is also
concerned with the ways in which
one manifold may be embedded
within another, such as the ways
a knotted circle may be embedded
in three-dimensional space.
A
mathematical knot is the
abstract result of first looping
and interlacing a piece of
string, then joining its ends
together. Because any such knot
is always topologically
equivalent to a circle, the
central questions in knot theory
concern how that curve is
embedded in three-dimensional
space.
Knot theorists are
particularly interested in
identifying when curves are
truly knotted, in finding ways
of distinguishing different
knots, and, more generally, in
classifying all possible knots.
Although a competent scout or
sailor can readily identify and
distinguish between a reef knot
and a granny knot,
mathematicians have a tougher
task because they must deal with
all conceivable knots. In many
cases, two knots may look the
same when, in fact, they are
different.
Alternatively, a knot may be so
contorted that its true identity
is masked. To make knot
classification easier,
investigators examine the
two-dimensional shadows cast by
the three-dimensional knots.
Even the most tangled
configuration can be pictured as
a continuous loop whose shadow
winds across a flat surface,
sometimes crossing over, and
sometimes crossing under itself.
One convenient measure of a
knot's complexity is the minimum
number of crossings that show up
after looking at all possible
shadows of a particular knot. A
loop without any twists of
crossings (in its simplest form,
a circle) is called an unknot.
The simplest possible knot is
the overhand, or trefoil, knot,
which is really just a circle
that winds through itself. In
its plainest form, this knot has
three crossings. It also comes
in two forms: left-handed and
right-handed configurations,
which are mirror images of each
other. Knot theorists have
identified 12,965 distinct knots
with 13 or fewer crossings.
A more sophisticated
approach to distinguishing knots
is to use the arrangement of
crossings in a knot diagram to
produce an algebraic
expression--a polynomial
invariant--that serves as a
label for the knot. Recent
discoveries of a wide range of
new invariants show promise
because they seem to distinguish
more different types of knots
than previously known
invariants.
Ivars Peterson
Bibliography:
Francis, G. K., A
Topological Picturebook (1987);
Firby, P, A., and
Gardiner, C. F., Surface
Topology (1982);
Barr, Stephen,
Experiments in Topology (1972);
Weeks, Jeffrey R., The
Shape of Space (1985);
Peterson, Ivars, Islands
of Truth (1990) and The
Mathematical Tourist (1988);
Stewart, Ian, The Problem
of Mathematics (1987).
|
|
|
____(To download an article, click on
the link. If you don't have
Acrobat Reader you can
download it by clicking
here)
|
|
Some of our
other pages about illiteracy :
Other web sites
on Topology or mathematics
Other web
sites on psychoanalysis
Forum reserved for psychoanalytic articles.
|
|
Enough with
"fighting against" illiteracy ! We work "with" and "for"
illiterate people ! |
|
Participate to the site, propose your
texts in English on psychoanalysis and/or illiteracy ! |
|
|
|
Sites for Teachers
Illiteracy, Illettrisme, psychanalyse, Analphabétisme et illettrisme,
Illettrisme - Lituraterre.org, Lituraterre.org, Prévention de l'illettrisme,
illettrisme et prévention, informer et sensibiliser le grand public mais
aussi aider soutenir et proposer du contenu adapté pour les chercheurs et
les enseignants ainsi que les personnes en difficultés, sexuation,
Lituraterre.org : Le site européen de recherche sur les causes de l'illettrisme, améliorer pour tous les possibilités d'accès au savoir ,
sexualité, information illettrisme, définition illettrisme, outil lutte
contre l'illettrisme, multimédia, ilettrisme, illetrisme, annuaire
illettrisme, Topologie, illettrisme et Topologie, bande Moebius, Tore, Nœud,
recueil de textes sur l'illettrisme, ressources illettrisme, lecture,
écriture, calcul, problème d'illettrisme, texte, littérature, difficulté,
handicap, Psychique, soutien pédagogie, méthodologie,
francès, en griego, en italiano, en inglés,
documentation, appui
méthodologique, appui pédagogique, éducation, lire, écrire, compter, savoirs
de base, maîtrise savoirs de base, compétences lettrées, Lettre, bas niveau
qualification, lutte contre les exclusions, illiteracy, literacy,
ILLETTERATISMO, Illettrismus, ILETRISMO, Freud, Lacan, Psychanalyse,
illettrisme et psychanalyse, Topologie, formation, enseignement, école, FLE,
français langue étrangère, formateur, formation formateurs, Groupe
psychanalytique européen de recherche et de formation sur les causes de l'illettrisme, prévention illettrisme et échec scolaire , alphabétisation,
analphabétisme, Psychanalyse et illettrisme, recherche formation sur
l'illettrisme, aide, Oui à une prévention et à l'élaboration d'une théorie
clinique de l'illettrisme, recueil de textes, Ressources illettrisme, Lutte
contre l'illettrisme, Illettrisme et Europe, causes illettrisme, groupe
européen illettrisme, illettrisme psychanalyse, Illettrisme en France,
ILETRISMO, index Lituraterre, Groupe de recherche psychanalytique sur les
causes de l'illettrisme, Une nouvelle définition de l'illettrisme, Assez de
la « lutte » contre l'illettrisme, oui à la prévention et à l'élaboration
d'une théorie clinique de l'illettrisme, français, french, allemand, deutsch,
italien, italiano, anglais, english, espagnol, spanish, german, grec,
topologie lacanienne, La théorie du nœud, signifiant, illettrés, la
métonymie, la métaphore, sexe, Autre discours, Autre, Réel, Lacan, Freud,
Rature d'aucune trace qui soit d'avant !
|